My first awareness of Fanny Wateman came in 1956, the year of an astonishing concert . This was when ten-year-old party- frocked Wendy Waterman(Fanny Waterman's niece) was led onto the stage of the Royal Festival Hall clutching Sir Malcolm Sargent's hand and played Bach's D minor Piano Concerto. Even today I can recall the freshness, vitality and articulacy of her performance prompting Annie Fisher, no less, to say she had never heard the Concerto better played. How was this possible? Curiosity throughout the music world was aroused and it was hardly surprising that in 1963, when Waterman launched the Leeds Piano Competition, the trump card of her career, she attracted the great and the good to be on her jury; Annie Fisher, Ivan Moravec, Gina Bachauer, Benjamin Britten, Clifford Curzon etc.
The facts of Waterman's rise to eminence are familiar, though it is worth repeating an anecdote, of her waking her husband during the night to announce 'let's have a piano competition here in Leeds.' Geoffrey de Keyser, Waterman's GP husband, strongly rejected the idea. Such events could only take place in a capitol city, in London, Paris or New York or a more attractive venue. After all you could hardly compare industrial Leeds with Venice or Oxford('the city of dreaming spires').But Waterman, a woman of formidable energy and determination, forged ahead regardless, and 'The Leeds,' as it became known, went on to become one of the most celebrated—for some the most celebrated-- competition in the world. The first event was won by Waterman's student Michael Roll, which caused consternation and accusations(though Waterman was chairman rather than a voting member of the jury.) It is also worth remembering Benjamin Britten's wonder at Roll's performance of Beethoven's opus 111 Sonata in particular. A lover of Mozart and Schubert rather than Beethoven he found himself reconsidering his preferences.
The competition hit a high spot in both 1969 and 1972 when it was won by Radu Lupu and Murray Perahia respectively, supreme artists rarely encountered in any venue let alone one as acoustically inadequate as the Leeds Town Hall. Jury member Ingrid Haebler was seen appearing and disappearing from view like the proverbial Cheshire Cat as she sought a place in the hall which provided a satisfactory listening experience. Later still Abbey Simon, another jury member, told me, 'I haven't heard a thing since I've been here The acoustic makes it virtually impossible to assess detail accurately, and detail is of the essence. The competition moved briefly to the Grand Theatre in Leeds where the sound-- as dry as dust-- was even worse. It returned to the Town Hall and plans for a Fanny Waterman concert hall failed to materialise.
Very much in Waterman's favour was her intervention in 1969 when Radu Lupu, prior to the semi-final, was voted out of the competition. Asking the jury whether they were interested in playing of the highest order, Waterman said that if Lupu was not reinstated she would leave the competition forever; 'as simple as that.' Suitably chastened the jury re-considered, and Lupu went on to win the competition with a still legendary performance of Beethoven's Third Concerto.
By now readers will have been made aware of a powerful and controversial figure. Waterman's energy and domination became legendary. She became both affectionately and unaffectionately known as 'Field Marshal Fanny.' I look back ruefully to an article I wrote in 1975 praising Waterman in unqualified terms. I recall her asking her son what he thought of my article and his reply, 'it makes you sound very intellectual.' 'But don't you think I am intellectual?' her reply. Waterman was indeed no intellectual but rather the possessor of sharp instincts put to practical advantage. Distressed by what she saw as the dilettantish and amateurish teaching in England, she retaliated with a method which she claimed was an elaboration of an approach by a violinist she knew in neighbouring Huddersfield. She had little or no use for terms such as 'genius' or the vague and inexplicable. There were reasons for, say, Sviatoslav Richter's stature, his technique, sonority, musicianship and all the elements that led to his standing. It was never a question of the mysterious, of the great unknown. Her students who at the earliest age flocked to her house in Leeds quickly learnt to know the why and wherefore of piano playing, how to implement 'fanny fingers,' 'overlaps,' ' and 'tops' etc. At last, she would create pianists who could compete at the highest level, with the sources of great playing from Russia, France, Hungary etc.
Not that the path to such promised success was easy. Many students fell by the wayside daunted and distressed by often ferocious and bullying demands. Gentle persuasion was not in Waterman's nature and children had to be strong to survive her often merciless assault. 'Don't dump in down like a sack of potatoes, you've got no quality to your sound,' 'the butterfly has landed on the wrong flower and is full of regret, and I can't hear any regret in your playing'(this in reference to an early bar in Schumann's 'Papillons') 'Don't wave your ams about in the air, it isn't lazy days.' 'You'll have to stop dear. I can't be expected to listen to playing like that. It's like so much knitting.' Praise was hard earned and her word was law. Many students(or pupils as Waterman preferred to call them) left in tears, disheartened and with their next lesson approached with dread.
My point at this juncture is to say that while such teaching produced results at one level it could also produce damage at another. As one of Waterman's most successful students put it, 'no lesson with Fanny was ever enjoyable.' Making a shrewd and necessary move and having acquired the foundation of a secure pianism he left to study with Oliver Messiane and his pianist wife Yvonne Loriod in Paris. Waterman was outraged, exclaiming 'you won't learn anything from them.' One got the impression that if you had said you were going to study with Beethoven the response would have been the same. Waterman was a woman oblivious to her limitations and as the above student put it, 'once she put her interpretive spoke in you could be seriously misled.' Musically, she had little notion of elusive issues that lay beyond the obvious, and advice even to her adult students such as 'graceful, like a swan' or bzzzz, like a wasp's nest' were hardly speculative.
Then there was the question of repertoire. As a co-jury colleague, I was alarmed when a gifted Czech pianist, Adam Skoumal came to me for advice after he had been eliminated from the competition. I had heard him on several occasion and admired not only his playing but also his enterprising repertoire. While his colleagues offered familiar, over-familiar works, the Mussorgsky Pictures, Beethoven's 'appassionata' etc Skoumal chose the Janacek Sonata and Schumann's B minor Allegro. When I complemented him on his choice, he told me that Waterman had advised him against his spirit of adventure; 'it's not good music.' Clearly, she did not know it and was lost outside her own narrow perspective and preference.
Many years later I joined the pianist Jacob Lateiner as a jury colleague at New York's Naumburg Competition. He spoke to me in an initially polite but then abrupt and inflammatory way. 'You are from London; you should be so lucky. I have played there many times. But tell me, there is a teacher in England, somewhere in the north. When I told him he must be thinking of Fanny Waterman it was like lighting a blue touch paper. 'We were together at a conference of the World Federation of International Music Competitions of which she was chairman and we had to listen to her instructing us on how to approach music. Thus, 'when I listen to Beethoven's 'appassionata' Sonata, if I don't think of a boat going out to sea before returning to the harbour I don't give the performance a good mark.' For Lateiner she seemed devoid of genuine musical knowledge let alone musical sophistication.'
In the long-term Waterman was a contradictory figure. Her limitation was both her virtue and her failing and it is a remarkable fact that very few of her students continued to achieve success. True, people who had previously known little about music were drawn into the gladiatorial atmosphere of 'The Leeds,' making their opinions loud and clear('The Russian girl, Victoria Postnikova, should win cos she's so bonny!') Of Waterman's resilience and achievement there can be no doubt. But the narrow and prescriptive nature of her teaching and its failure to advance beyond itself, is a matter of regret. Music and its performance are multi-faceted arts that can never be easily defined and reduced.
Bryce Morrison